• January
  • February
  • March
  • April
  • May
  • June
  • July
  • August
  • September
  • October
  • November
  • December
  • 1945
  • January, 1945

    January

  • February, 1945

    February

  • March, 1945

    March

  • April, 1945

    April

  • May, 1945

    May

  • June, 1945

    June

  • July, 1945

    July

  • August, 1945

    August

  • September, 1945

    September

  • October, 1945

    October

  • November, 1945

    November

  • December, 1945

    December

  • 1946
  • January, 1946

    January

  • February, 1946

    February

  • March, 1946

    March

  • April, 1946

    April

  • May, 1946

    May

  • June, 1946

    June

  • July, 1946

    July

  • August, 1946

    August

  • September, 1946

    September

  • October, 1946

    October

  • November, 1946

    November

  • December, 1946

    December

  • 1947
  • January, 1947

    January

  • February, 1947

    February

  • March, 1947

    March

  • April, 1947

    April

  • May, 1947

    May

  • June, 1947

    June

  • July, 1947

    July

  • August, 1947

    August

  • September, 1947

    September

  • October, 1947

    October

  • November, 1947

    November

  • December, 1947

    December

  • 1948
  • January, 1948

    January

  • February, 1948

    February

  • March, 1948

    March

  • April, 1948

    April

  • May, 1948

    May

  • June, 1948

    June

  • July, 1948

    July

  • August, 1948

    August

  • September, 1948

    September

  • October, 1948

    October

  • November, 1948

    November

  • December, 1948

    December

  • 1949
  • January, 1949

    January

  • February, 1949

    February

  • March, 1949

    March

  • April, 1949

    April

  • May, 1949

    May

  • June, 1949

    June

  • July, 1949

    July

  • August, 1949

    August

  • September, 1949

    September

  • October, 1949

    October

  • November, 1949

    November

  • December, 1949

    December

  • 1950
  • January, 1950

    January

  • February, 1950

    February

  • March, 1950

    March

  • April, 1950

    April

  • May, 1950

    May

  • June, 1950

    June

  • July, 1950

    July

  • August, 1950

    August

  • September, 1950

    September

  • October, 1950

    October

  • November, 1950

    November

  • December, 1950

    December

  • 1951
  • January, 1951

    January

  • February, 1951

    February

  • March, 1951

    March

  • April, 1951

    April

  • May, 1951

    May

  • June, 1951

    June

  • July, 1951

    July

  • August, 1951

    August

  • September, 1951

    September

  • October, 1951

    October

  • November, 1951

    November

  • December, 1951

    December

  • 1952
  • January, 1952

    January

  • February, 1952

    February

  • March, 1952

    March

  • April, 1952

    April

  • May, 1952

    May

  • June, 1952

    June

  • July, 1952

    July

  • August, 1952

    August

  • September, 1952

    September

  • October, 1952

    October

  • November, 1952

    November

  • December, 1952

    December

  • 1953
  • January, 1953

    January

  • February, 1953

    February

  • March, 1953

    March

  • April, 1953

    April

  • May, 1953

    May

  • June, 1953

    June

  • July, 1953

    July

  • August, 1953

    August

  • September, 1953

    September

  • October, 1953

    October

  • November, 1953

    November

  • December, 1953

    December

  • 1954
  • January, 1954

    January

  • February, 1954

    February

  • March, 1954

    March

  • April, 1954

    April

  • May, 1954

    May

  • June, 1954

    June

  • July, 1954

    July

  • August, 1954

    August

  • September, 1954

    September

  • October, 1954

    October

  • November, 1954

    November

  • December, 1954

    December

  • 1955
  • January, 1955

    January

  • February, 1955

    February

  • March, 1955

    March

  • April, 1955

    April

  • May, 1955

    May

  • June, 1955

    June

  • July, 1955

    July

  • August, 1955

    August

  • September, 1955

    September

  • October, 1955

    October

  • November, 1955

    November

  • December, 1955

    December

  • 1956
  • January, 1956

    January

  • February, 1956

    February

  • March, 1956

    March

  • April, 1956

    April

  • May, 1956

    May

  • June, 1956

    June

  • July, 1956

    July

  • August, 1956

    August

  • September, 1956

    September

  • October, 1956

    October

  • November, 1956

    November

  • December, 1956

    December

  • 1957
  • January, 1957

    January

  • February, 1957

    February

  • March, 1957

    March

  • April, 1957

    April

  • May, 1957

    May

  • June, 1957

    June

  • July, 1957

    July

  • August, 1957

    August

  • September, 1957

    September

  • October, 1957

    October

  • November, 1957

    November

  • December, 1957

    December

  • 1958
  • January, 1958

    January

  • February, 1958

    February

  • March, 1958

    March

  • April, 1958

    April

  • May, 1958

    May

  • June, 1958

    June

  • July, 1958

    July

  • August, 1958

    August

  • September, 1958

    September

  • October, 1958

    October

  • November, 1958

    November

  • December, 1958

    December

  • 1959
  • January, 1959

    January

  • February, 1959

    February

  • March, 1959

    March

  • April, 1959

    April

  • May, 1959

    May

  • June, 1959

    June

  • July, 1959

    July

  • August, 1959

    August

  • September, 1959

    September

  • October, 1959

    October

  • November, 1959

    November

  • December, 1959

    December

  • 1960
  • January, 1960

    January

  • February, 1960

    February

  • March, 1960

    March

  • April, 1960

    April

  • May, 1960

    May

  • June, 1960

    June

  • July, 1960

    July

  • August, 1960

    August

  • September, 1960

    September

  • October, 1960

    October

  • November, 1960

    November

  • December, 1960

    December

  • 1961
  • January, 1961

    January

  • February, 1961

    February

  • March, 1961

    March

  • April, 1961

    April

  • May, 1961

    May

  • June, 1961

    June

  • July, 1961

    July

  • August, 1961

    August

  • September, 1961

    September

  • October, 1961

    October

  • November, 1961

    November

  • December, 1961

    December

  • 1962
  • January, 1962

    January

  • February, 1962

    February

  • March, 1962

    March

  • April, 1962

    April

  • May, 1962

    May

  • June, 1962

    June

  • July, 1962

    July

  • August, 1962

    August

  • September, 1962

    September

  • October, 1962

    October

  • November, 1962

    November

  • December, 1962

    December

  • 1963
  • January, 1963

    January

  • February, 1963

    February

  • March, 1963

    March

  • April, 1963

    April

  • May, 1963

    May

  • June, 1963

    June

  • July, 1963

    July

  • August, 1963

    August

  • September, 1963

    September

  • October, 1963

    October

  • November, 1963

    November

  • December, 1963

    December

  • 1964
  • January, 1964

    January

  • February, 1964

    February

  • March, 1964

    March

  • April, 1964

    April

  • May, 1964

    May

  • June, 1964

    June

  • July, 1964

    July

  • August, 1964

    August

  • September, 1964

    September

  • October, 1964

    October

  • November, 1964

    November

  • December, 1964

    December

  • 1965
  • January, 1965

    January

  • February, 1965

    February

  • March, 1965

    March

  • April, 1965

    April

  • May, 1965

    May

  • June, 1965

    June

  • July, 1965

    July

  • August, 1965

    August

  • September, 1965

    September

  • October, 1965

    October

  • November, 1965

    November

  • December, 1965

    December

  • 1966
  • January, 1966

    January

  • February, 1966

    February

  • March, 1966

    March

  • April, 1966

    April

  • May, 1966

    May

  • June, 1966

    June

  • July, 1966

    July

  • August, 1966

    August

  • September, 1966

    September

  • October, 1966

    October

  • November, 1966

    November

  • December, 1966

    December

  • 1967
  • January, 1967

    January

  • February, 1967

    February

  • March, 1967

    March

  • April, 1967

    April

  • May, 1967

    May

  • June, 1967

    June

  • July, 1967

    July

  • August, 1967

    August

  • September, 1967

    September

  • October, 1967

    October

  • November, 1967

    November

  • December, 1967

    December

  • 1968
  • January, 1968

    January

  • February, 1968

    February

  • March, 1968

    March

  • April, 1968

    April

  • May, 1968

    May

  • June, 1968

    June

  • July, 1968

    July

  • August, 1968

    August

  • September, 1968

    September

  • October, 1968

    October

  • November, 1968

    November

  • December, 1968

    December

  • 1969
  • January, 1969

    January

  • February, 1969

    February

  • March, 1969

    March

  • April, 1969

    April

  • May, 1969

    May

  • June, 1969

    June

  • July, 1969

    July

  • August, 1969

    August

  • September, 1969

    September

  • October, 1969

    October

  • November, 1969

    November

  • December, 1969

    December

  • 1970
  • January, 1970

    January

  • February, 1970

    February

  • March, 1970

    March

  • April, 1970

    April

  • May, 1970

    May

  • June, 1970

    June

  • July, 1970

    July

  • August, 1970

    August

  • September, 1970

    September

  • October, 1970

    October

  • November, 1970

    November

  • December, 1970

    December

  • 1971
  • January, 1971

    January

  • February, 1971

    February

  • March, 1971

    March

  • April, 1971

    April

  • May, 1971

    May

  • June, 1971

    June

  • July, 1971

    July

  • August, 1971

    August

  • September, 1971

    September

  • October, 1971

    October

  • November, 1971

    November

  • December, 1971

    December

  • 1972
  • January, 1972

    January

  • February, 1972

    February

  • March, 1972

    March

  • April, 1972

    April

  • May, 1972

    May

  • June, 1972

    June

  • July, 1972

    July

  • August, 1972

    August

  • September, 1972

    September

  • October, 1972

    October

  • November, 1972

    November

  • December, 1972

    December

  • 1973
  • January, 1973

    January

  • February, 1973

    February

  • March, 1973

    March

  • April, 1973

    April

  • May, 1973

    May

  • June, 1973

    June

  • July, 1973

    July

  • August, 1973

    August

  • September, 1973

    September

  • October, 1973

    October

  • November, 1973

    November

  • December, 1973

    December

  • 1974
  • January, 1974

    January

  • February, 1974

    February

  • March, 1974

    March

  • April, 1974

    April

  • May, 1974

    May

  • June, 1974

    June

  • July, 1974

    July

  • August, 1974

    August

  • September, 1974

    September

  • October, 1974

    October

  • November, 1974

    November

  • December, 1974

    December

  • 1975
  • January, 1975

    January

  • February, 1975

    February

  • March, 1975

    March

  • April, 1975

    April

  • May, 1975

    May

  • June, 1975

    June

  • July, 1975

    July

  • August, 1975

    August

  • September, 1975

    September

  • October, 1975

    October

  • November, 1975

    November

  • December, 1975

    December

  • 1976
  • January, 1976

    January

  • February, 1976

    February

  • March, 1976

    March

  • April, 1976

    April

  • May, 1976

    May

  • June, 1976

    June

  • July, 1976

    July

  • August, 1976

    August

  • September, 1976

    September

  • October, 1976

    October

  • November, 1976

    November

  • December, 1976

    December

  • 1977
  • January, 1977

    January

  • February, 1977

    February

  • March, 1977

    March

  • April, 1977

    April

  • May, 1977

    May

  • June, 1977

    June

  • July, 1977

    July

  • August, 1977

    August

  • September, 1977

    September

  • October, 1977

    October

  • November, 1977

    November

  • December, 1977

    December

  • 1978
  • January, 1978

    January

  • February, 1978

    February

  • March, 1978

    March

  • April, 1978

    April

  • May, 1978

    May

  • June, 1978

    June

  • July, 1978

    July

  • August, 1978

    August

  • September, 1978

    September

  • October, 1978

    October

  • November, 1978

    November

  • December, 1978

    December

  • 1979
  • January, 1979

    January

  • February, 1979

    February

  • March, 1979

    March

  • April, 1979

    April

  • May, 1979

    May

  • June, 1979

    June

  • July, 1979

    July

  • August, 1979

    August

  • September, 1979

    September

  • October, 1979

    October

  • November, 1979

    November

  • December, 1979

    December

  • 1980
  • January, 1980

    January

  • February, 1980

    February

  • March, 1980

    March

  • April, 1980

    April

  • May, 1980

    May

  • June, 1980

    June

  • July, 1980

    July

  • August, 1980

    August

  • September, 1980

    September

  • October, 1980

    October

  • November, 1980

    November

  • December, 1980

    December

  • 1981
  • January, 1981

    January

  • February, 1981

    February

  • March, 1981

    March

  • April, 1981

    April

  • May, 1981

    May

  • June, 1981

    June

  • July, 1981

    July

  • August, 1981

    August

  • September, 1981

    September

  • October, 1981

    October

  • November, 1981

    November

  • December, 1981

    December

  • 1982
  • January, 1982

    January

  • February, 1982

    February

  • March, 1982

    March

  • April, 1982

    April

  • May, 1982

    May

  • June, 1982

    June

  • July, 1982

    July

  • August, 1982

    August

  • September, 1982

    September

  • October, 1982

    October

  • November, 1982

    November

  • December, 1982

    December

  • 1983
  • January, 1983

    January

  • February, 1983

    February

  • March, 1983

    March

  • April, 1983

    April

  • May, 1983

    May

  • June, 1983

    June

  • July, 1983

    July

  • August, 1983

    August

  • September, 1983

    September

  • October, 1983

    October

  • November, 1983

    November

  • December, 1983

    December

  • 1984
  • January, 1984

    January

  • February, 1984

    February

  • March, 1984

    March

  • April, 1984

    April

  • May, 1984

    May

  • June, 1984

    June

  • July, 1984

    July

  • August, 1984

    August

  • September, 1984

    September

  • October, 1984

    October

  • November, 1984

    November

  • December, 1984

    December

  • 1985
  • January, 1985

    January

  • February, 1985

    February

  • March, 1985

    March

  • April, 1985

    April

  • May, 1985

    May

  • June, 1985

    June

  • July, 1985

    July

  • August, 1985

    August

  • September, 1985

    September

  • October, 1985

    October

  • November, 1985

    November

  • December, 1985

    December

  • 1986
  • January, 1986

    January

  • February, 1986

    February

  • March, 1986

    March

  • April, 1986

    April

  • May, 1986

    May

  • June, 1986

    June

  • July, 1986

    July

  • August, 1986

    August

  • September, 1986

    September

  • October, 1986

    October

  • November, 1986

    November

  • December, 1986

    December

  • 1987
  • January, 1987

    January

  • February, 1987

    February

  • March, 1987

    March

  • April, 1987

    April

  • May, 1987

    May

  • June, 1987

    June

  • July, 1987

    July

  • August, 1987

    August

  • September, 1987

    September

  • October, 1987

    October

  • November, 1987

    November

  • December, 1987

    December

  • 1988
  • January, 1988

    January

  • February, 1988

    February

  • March, 1988

    March

  • April, 1988

    April

  • May, 1988

    May

  • June, 1988

    June

  • July, 1988

    July

  • August, 1988

    August

  • September, 1988

    September

  • October, 1988

    October

  • November, 1988

    November

  • December, 1988

    December

  • 1989
  • January, 1989

    January

  • February, 1989

    February

  • March, 1989

    March

  • April, 1989

    April

  • May, 1989

    May

  • June, 1989

    June

  • July, 1989

    July

  • August, 1989

    August

  • September, 1989

    September

  • October, 1989

    October

  • November, 1989

    November

  • December, 1989

    December

  • 1990
  • January, 1990

    January

  • February, 1990

    February

  • March, 1990

    March

  • April, 1990

    April

  • May, 1990

    May

  • June, 1990

    June

  • July, 1990

    July

  • August, 1990

    August

  • September, 1990

    September

  • October, 1990

    October

  • November, 1990

    November

  • December, 1990

    December

  • 1991
  • January, 1991

    January

  • February, 1991

    February

  • March, 1991

    March

  • April, 1991

    April

  • May, 1991

    May

  • June, 1991

    June

  • July, 1991

    July

  • August, 1991

    August

  • September, 1991

    September

  • October, 1991

    October

  • November, 1991

    November

  • December, 1991

    December

  • 1992
  • January, 1992

    January

  • February, 1992

    February

  • March, 1992

    March

  • April, 1992

    April

  • May, 1992

    May

  • June, 1992

    June

  • July, 1992

    July

  • August, 1992

    August

  • September, 1992

    September

  • October, 1992

    October

  • November, 1992

    November

  • December, 1992

    December

  • 1993
  • January, 1993

    January

  • February, 1993

    February

  • March, 1993

    March

  • April, 1993

    April

  • May, 1993

    May

  • June, 1993

    June

  • July, 1993

    July

  • August, 1993

    August

  • September, 1993

    September

  • October, 1993

    October

  • November, 1993

    November

  • December, 1993

    December

  • 1994
  • January, 1994

    January

  • February, 1994

    February

  • March, 1994

    March

  • April, 1994

    April

  • May, 1994

    May

  • June, 1994

    June

  • July, 1994

    July

  • August, 1994

    August

  • September, 1994

    September

  • October, 1994

    October

  • November, 1994

    November

  • December, 1994

    December

  • 1995
  • January, 1995

    January

  • February, 1995

    February

  • March, 1995

    March

  • April, 1995

    April

  • May, 1995

    May

  • June, 1995

    June

  • July, 1995

    July

  • August, 1995

    August

  • September, 1995

    September

  • October, 1995

    October

  • November, 1995

    November

  • December, 1995

    December

  • 1996
  • January, 1996

    January

  • February, 1996

    February

  • March, 1996

    March

  • April, 1996

    April

  • May, 1996

    May

  • June, 1996

    June

  • July, 1996

    July

  • August, 1996

    August

  • September, 1996

    September

  • October, 1996

    October

  • November, 1996

    November

  • December, 1996

    December

  • 1997
  • January, 1997

    January

  • February, 1997

    February

  • March, 1997

    March

  • April, 1997

    April

  • May, 1997

    May

  • June, 1997

    June

  • July, 1997

    July

  • August, 1997

    August

  • September, 1997

    September

  • October, 1997

    October

  • November, 1997

    November

  • December, 1997

    December

  • 1998
  • January, 1998

    January

  • February, 1998

    February

  • March, 1998

    March

  • April, 1998

    April

  • May, 1998

    May

  • June, 1998

    June

  • July, 1998

    July

  • August, 1998

    August

  • September, 1998

    September

  • October, 1998

    October

  • November, 1998

    November

  • December, 1998

    December

  • 1999
  • January, 1999

    January

  • February, 1999

    February

  • March, 1999

    March

  • April, 1999

    April

  • May, 1999

    May

  • June, 1999

    June

  • July, 1999

    July

  • August, 1999

    August

  • September, 1999

    September

  • October, 1999

    October

  • November, 1999

    November

  • December, 1999

    December

  • 2000
  • January, 2000

    January

  • February, 2000

    February

  • March, 2000

    March

  • April, 2000

    April

  • May, 2000

    May

  • June, 2000

    June

  • July, 2000

    July

  • August, 2000

    August

  • September, 2000

    September

  • October, 2000

    October

  • November, 2000

    November

  • December, 2000

    December

  • 2001
  • January, 2001

    January

  • February, 2001

    February

  • March, 2001

    March

  • April, 2001

    April

  • May, 2001

    May

  • June, 2001

    June

  • July, 2001

    July

  • August, 2001

    August

  • September, 2001

    September

  • October, 2001

    October

  • November, 2001

    November

  • December, 2001

    December

  • 2002
  • January, 2002

    January

  • February, 2002

    February

  • March, 2002

    March

  • April, 2002

    April

  • May, 2002

    May

  • June, 2002

    June

  • July, 2002

    July

  • August, 2002

    August

  • September, 2002

    September

  • October, 2002

    October

  • November, 2002

    November

  • December, 2002

    December

  • 2003
  • January, 2003

    January

  • February, 2003

    February

  • March, 2003

    March

  • April, 2003

    April

  • May, 2003

    May

  • June, 2003

    June

  • July, 2003

    July

  • August, 2003

    August

  • September, 2003

    September

  • October, 2003

    October

  • November, 2003

    November

  • December, 2003

    December

  • 2004
  • January, 2004

    January

  • February, 2004

    February

  • March, 2004

    March

  • April, 2004

    April

  • May, 2004

    May

  • June, 2004

    June

  • July, 2004

    July

  • August, 2004

    August

  • September, 2004

    September

  • October, 2004

    October

  • November, 2004

    November

  • December, 2004

    December

  • 2005
  • January, 2005

    January

  • February, 2005

    February

  • March, 2005

    March

  • April, 2005

    April

  • May, 2005

    May

  • June, 2005

    June

  • July, 2005

    July

  • August, 2005

    August

  • September, 2005

    September

  • October, 2005

    October

  • November, 2005

    November

  • December, 2005

    December

  • 2006
  • January, 2006

    January

  • February, 2006

    February

  • March, 2006

    March

  • April, 2006

    April

  • May, 2006

    May

  • June, 2006

    June

  • July, 2006

    July

  • August, 2006

    August

  • September, 2006

    September

  • October, 2006

    October

  • November, 2006

    November

  • December, 2006

    December

  • 2007
  • January, 2007

    January

  • February, 2007

    February

  • March, 2007

    March

  • April, 2007

    April

  • May, 2007

    May

  • June, 2007

    June

  • July, 2007

    July

  • August, 2007

    August

  • September, 2007

    September

  • October, 2007

    October

  • November, 2007

    November

  • December, 2007

    December

  • 2008
  • January, 2008

    January

  • February, 2008

    February

  • March, 2008

    March

  • April, 2008

    April

  • May, 2008

    May

  • June, 2008

    June

  • July, 2008

    July

  • August, 2008

    August

  • September, 2008

    September

  • October, 2008

    October

  • November, 2008

    November

  • December, 2008

    December

  • 2009
  • January, 2009

    January

  • February, 2009

    February

  • March, 2009

    March

  • April, 2009

    April

  • May, 2009

    May

  • June, 2009

    June

  • July, 2009

    July

  • August, 2009

    August

  • September, 2009

    September

  • October, 2009

    October

  • November, 2009

    November

  • December, 2009

    December

* *

Timelines

Essays

Essays

The second Gwangju Biennale, Poster, 1997, Courtesy of the Gwangju Biennale Foundation.
Postcolonial Subjects in the Age of Globalisation: Unmapping the Earth (1997) and Annual Report (2008)

The thematic focus of the first Gwangju Biennale—“the coexistence and harmony of humankind”—was, to a certain extent, overshadowed by the celebratory nature of its auxiliary programs, such as performances and marketplaces, rather than the exhibition itself. In response to these limitations, the second Gwangju Biennale, Unmapping the Earth (September 1 – November 28, 1997), sought to restructure both its curatorial and organizational frameworks to strengthen the substance of its content. To this end, the Gwangju Biennale Foundation undertook overall curatorial control and established five thematic keywords—speed, space, hybrid, power, and becoming—as a guideline of the exhibition. Five co-commissioners (Harald Szeemann, Bernard Marcadé, Richard Koshalek, Sung Wan-Kyung, and Park Kyong) were appointed to curate the exhibition in accordance with these themes. At the time, Lee Youngchul, Head of the Foundation’s Curatorial Team, was responsible for keyword development, inviting curator, and the planning of academic programs. The Korean title of this exhibition, which literally translates to “Margin of the Earth,” and the English title Unmapping of the Earth collectively articulate a curatorial intent to challenge colonial epistemologies and the cartographic power structures inherent in Western map-making practices. At the same time, they endeavor to reimagine the “margins” as a new global order and explore the potential of constructing worlds through art.1 Curator Lee Youngchul brought attention to the dialogue between two shadows in the “Equality of Things” chapter in the book of Zhuangzi, to ground his curatorial framework in the Eastern philosophical principle of relationality. Building on this foundation, he proposed a hybridized network model that interlinks discrete exhibitions. By referencing the dialogue between a dark shadow aware of its origin and a pale shadow that lingers on the boundary of the silhouette, Lee frames curatorial practice as a critical apparatus through which to interrogate and negotiate the dynamics of center and periphery, identity and boundary, hierarchy and equality- recurring themes within discourses of globalization.2 He further associated each thematic keyword with elements of Eastern philosophy, with specific reference to the theory of yin-yang and the five elements. Speed/Water represents a nomadic conception of time, transcending both the linear temporality of the West and the cyclical characteristic of the East. Space/Fire symbolizes glocalization, marking the convergence of global urbanization paradigms with local particularities. While Hybrid/Wood engages with the proliferation of diasporic identities and transnationalism, Power/Metal encompasses both institutional authority and the micro-power dynamics embedded in everyday life. Becoming/Earth explores the body as a concept intimately connected to the land. Unmapping the Earth (1997): Mapping Hybridity Through a Deconstructive Lens The simultaneous integration of Western deconstructivism and Eastern philosophy within the curatorial framework may be attributed to the influence of globalization—a phenomenon in which all the disparate elements converge and intermingle. Indeed, exploring the complex implications of globalization requires interdisciplinary approaches, drawing from sociology, economics, and philosophy and so on. In this regard, the philosophical critiques included in the exhibition catalogue are worthy of renewed attention. Paul Virilio interprets globalization through the lens of technological development, which has led to intensified population concentration and enhanced media-based control and surveillance, as well as the emergence of collective identities and virtual realities in online spaces.3 Slavoj Žižek contends that under global capitalism, multinational capital deterritorializes and produces an automated colonial system. Within this structure, multiculturalism and ethnonationalist fundamentalism coexist and often intersect.4 Žižek is critical of multiculturalism for reducing “the Other” to a fixed identity, thereby perpetuating new forms of exclusion. This critique aligns closely with the curatorial themes explored in the second Gwangju Biennale.5 Meanwhile, a symposium held in conjunction with the biennale (October 30–31, 1997) addressed themes of postcolonialism and cultural translation, featuring theorist Gayatri Spivak as a keynote speaker.6 In a session entitled “Globalization and Postcolonialism,” sociologist Han Sang-Jin proposed that the complexities of the world should be interpreted from the standpoint of Korea and Asia, and that fostering mutual understanding between Eastern and Western cultures could serve as a means to overcome cultural colonialism.7 In another session titled “Politics of Identity, Art and the Cultural Politics,” cultural theorist Lawrence Grossberg argued that new concepts in cultural geography are essential for articulating the shifting dynamics of culture and media, as conventional geographic and economic frameworks no longer suffice.8 The second Gwangju Biennale aimed to actively expand discourses on the political, social, and cultural impacts of globalization through the medium of the exhibition. While the biennale sustained the success of its inaugural exhibition, with 117 participating artists from thirty-five countries and approximately 970,000 visitors, the reception of the exhibited works proved notably more restrained than expected. Critic Chiba Shigeo argued that the conceptual integration of the five exhibitions into a hybrid entity was excessively abstract, further criticizing a tendency for reducing artworks to mere samples subordinated to the exhibition’s overarching themes.9 Art critic Lee Yongwoo also criticized the lack of coherence, pointing out that the participation of high-profile curators, such as Harald Szeemann, who was concurrently involved in curating the Lyon Biennale in the same year, diluted the curatorial sharpness. Lee further contended that the exhibition was undermined by a lack of newly commissioned works, thereby diminishing its overall impact.10 Ultimately, the disconnection between the exhibited works and the organizers’ intention is attributed to a structural weakness, namely, the absence of a general artistic director with overarching curatorial oversight. What is most regrettable is the diminished presence of the “Gwangju Spirit,” deeply rooted in the city’s modern history, within the exhibition itself. In 1995, artists of Gwangju, opposing the government-led direction of the Gwangju Biennale, held the Anti Gwangju Biennale at the Mangwol-dong Cemetery (now part of the May 18th National Cemetery). A funeral procession performance, featuring a bier symbolizing the wounds of the democratization movement and hundreds of funeral banners sent by protestors nationwide left an enduring impression. However, in 1997, the festival was abruptly incorporated into the biennale’s official side programs following the appointment of Kang Yeongyun—one of the original organizers of the Anti Gwangju Biennale—as both Secretary-General of the Gwangju Biennale Foundation and Director of the Gwangju Museum of Art. The ambitious curatorial vision of cultivating new cultural subjectivities and articulating counter-discourses in the era of globalization was swiftly overtaken by the logic of institutional politics, before it could yield meaningful aesthetic or political achievements. Given the second Gwangju Biennale’s original aim to foreground political expression through exhibition, it is worthwhile considering the example of the 2nd Johannesburg Biennale, held that same year in the Southern Hemisphere. Established in 1995, the same year as Gwangju, in the wake of the abolition of apartheid, the Johannesburg Biennale emphasized human rights. Its second edition, Trade Routes: History and Geography (October 10–December 12, 1997), critically engaged with multiculturalism, postcolonialism, and globalization as structural conditions that sustain colonial legacies. The thematic alignment with the second Gwangju Biennale is particularly noteworthy. Artistic Director Okwui Enwezor broke from the national pavilion model of the inaugural exhibition by appointing five co-curators (Gerardo Mosquera, Kellie Jones, Hou Hanru, Kim Yuyeon, Octavio Zaya, and Colin Richards), each of whom curated an independent exhibition. These shows were staged simultaneously in Johannesburg and the capital, Cape Town, an effort that highlighted glocalization by recognizing the particularities of local contexts within global frameworks. The biennale is widely considered a pivotal moment, marking a shift toward discourse-driven curatorial practices in twenty-first-century international biennales.11 Although it was prematurely terminated due to financial constraints, the second Johannesburg Biennale left a lasting impact. Its curators continued to play central roles in the international art world. Okwui Enwezor later became the Artistic Director of Documenta 11 (June. 8 – Sept. 15, 2002) and the seventh Gwangju Biennale (Sept. 5 – Nov. 9, 2008); Kim Yuyeon co-curated the third Gwangju Biennale Man+Space (Mar. 29 – June 7, 2000); and Hou Hanru co-curated both the traveling exhibition Cities on the Move (1997–1999) and the fourth Gwangju Biennale P_A_U_S_E (Mar. 29 – June 29, 2002). Annual Report (2008): Reflections on Glocalization and a Discursive Turn in Exhibition Practice In 1997, the experimental platform 100 Days—100 Guests was also launched, using Documenta 10 as its stage in an effort to bring about a discursive shift in exhibition-making. The platform elevated scholarly discourse by dedicating 100 consecutive days to presentations by a diverse array of intellectuals, positioning academic engagement at the center of the exhibition. Documenta 11 in 2002 continued this discursive turn by introducing five “platforms” located across Kassel, New Delhi, Lagos, Berlin, Vienna, and St. Lucia. It sought to critically examine global inequality and postcolonial conditions. In his influential 2004 essay, “Mega-Exhibitions and the Antinomies of a Transnational Global Form,” Okwui Enwezor referenced Johannesburg, Kassel, and Gwangju together, advocating for a reconfiguration of modernity through the complex cultural-political strategies of postcolonial subjectivity. For the postcolonial state the pressure to modernize and develop not only the superstructure of the state, but also the substructure of culture became the contemporary manual for exiting peripheralization. Modernity as such, and the desire to modernize, that is, to leave behind backwardness, became a tacit agreement to re-westernize, to be reintegrated into a neocolonial scheme in the name of progress, institutional development, and access to technology. It is in light of these two movements—between modernity and modernization—that certain forms of mega exhibition and museum can be understood. [...] Modernity and modernization mean, then, not only to develop a greater proximity to the institutional patronage of international artistic spheres but also to acquire and master its language, to harvest its surplus resources, and ultimately to position and promote the periphery as a genuine destination of artistic modernity.12 This curatorial approach, using exhibitions as a medium to reframe history and politics, has become a discursive foundation for twenty-first-century biennials, while also igniting intense debate. Art historian George Baker expressed concern that although large-scale exhibitions aim to transnationally link artists, the art market, and institutions, they risk alienating the public. In such cases, he argues, exhibitions no longer serve as a conduit for innovation but become institutionalized within a bureaucratic framework.13 In contrast, political theorist Oliver Marchart praised Okwui Enwezor’s strategy of “de-centering the West,” noting that it not only exposed the colonial history of European art but also created a new space for agonistic engagement between Documenta and its audiences.14 “Documenta 11 effectively repositioned transformations of canon emerging from the periphery as central to the imagined core of the Western art system.”15 In 2008, Okwui Enwezor became the first foreign artistic director of the seventh Gwangju Biennale, Annual Report (September 5 – November 9, 2008). A total of 127 artists from thirty-six countries participated in this exhibition, which was structured into three main parts. Firstly, On the Road: This section featured 36 exhibitions held globally between 2007 and mid-2008, presented either in their entirety or through selected works. Secondly, Position Papers: This expanded the exhibition space beyond the conventional biennale venues by encompassing art museums, markets, and movie local across Gwangju. Thirdly, Insertions: A section dedicated to new commissioned projects. The artistic director, together with curators Kim Hyunjin and Ranjit Hoskote as his associates, oversaw the overall planning. The Position Papers brought together five independently curated shows, led by Korean and international curators selected by the artistic director, into a unified composite structure. Another defining feature was the notable expansion of educational and research initiatives, exemplified by the relay-format plenary session held in Seoul and Beijing (August 29 – October 31, 2008). In order to explore critical issues in post-1980 Korean art, scholars and critics including Park Chan-kyong, Lee Youngwook, Sim Sang Yong, Seo Dongjin, and Moon Young Min engaged in presentations and discussions. A symposium was also convened under the theme of “Formations of Global Civil Society and Domains of Public Culture.” In this light, Enwezor analyzed May 18 Gwangju Democratization Movement and the June Democratic Uprising in 1987 as key drivers for dismantling military dictatorship, linking them to global patterns of postcolonial cultural resistance.16 Moreover, the international educational program “Global Institute” (August 11 – September 27, 2008) was hosted at Chonnam National University and Korea National University of Arts. A total of twenty-five lecturers including curators, architects, and sociologists delivered talks to fifty-two participants selected from both Korea and abroad.17 In his lecture, Enwezor attributed the post-1990s proliferation of new biennales to a paradigm shift where globalization replaced internationalization, driven by the erosion of national borders, increased mobility, and heightened nomadism. “Through vertical and horizontal global networks—north and south, east and west—art now moves multidirectionally. Globalization entails the formation of new cartographies, which induce changes in identity. As spatial concepts contract and weaken, deeper visions emerge. The deconstruction of dominant ideologies further accentuates the dichotomy between center and periphery.”18 Ranjit Hoskote, one of the curators of the seventh Gwangju Biennale, emphasized the discursive environment fostered by the exhibition, education, and research programs of Annual Report as a key achievement. “The exhibition offered curatorial formats in diverse scales and configurations, allowing viewers to move freely from intimate small-scale exhibitions to major solo shows, and from individual galleries to collective displays. This curatorial diversity transformed the biennale from a site of passive consumption into a platform that posed fundamental questions such as: ‘Why do we organize exhibitions?’, ‘Is an exhibition a repository of themes or a site of intellectual production?’, and ‘Can the biennale function as a temporary museum and archive?’, thus inviting multiple interpretations and engaging a multiplicity of publics.”19 This approach represents a meta-reflection on the exhibition as an institutional form, probing its potential to function as a public sphere and to evolve into a new medium of expression and language, thereby facilitating reflection on past, present, and future.20 In addition, it is worth emphasizing that a key factor underpinning the success of the Gwangju Biennale was its integration of exhibition and discourse-production closely attuned to the specificities of Gwangju, the Jeollanam-do Province, and South Korea. For example, Park Sung Hyen’s Bokdukbang Project, part of the Position Papers, was an exhibition rooted in the curator’s lived experience and engagement with the local community of Gwangju. Equally important was that the emergence of voices in the public sphere was not external, but internal. In order to trace the trajectories of contemporary Korean art and criticism from the 1980s, there was an attempt to revisit modernism, Minjung art, and postmodern criticism—not solely to address artistic issues, but to critically engage with issues grounded in social realities such as neoliberalism. Meanwhile, Patrick Flores, a co-curator for the Position Papers section in 2008, recently remarked on the current state of postcolonialism in Southeast Asia during a symposium reevaluating regionality in Asia.21 “Southeast Asia remains closely tied to coloniality, and in postcolonial discourse, the Philippines is often considered peripheral or even external. The plural agencies of production and the formation of institutional concepts continue to pose critical questions.” This suggests the enduring relevance of postcolonial discourse. In a present shaped simultaneously by unresolved historical issues and ongoing globalization, what significance can the voices of Asia hold? Carol Yinghua Lu, a co-artistic director of the 2024 Yokohama Triennale, calls for a critical rethinking of the concepts that frame contemporary art. “We must critically examine the institutional frameworks that constitute contemporary art, reaffirm the meanings of vision and history, and renew everyday life by constructing new and resilient structures.”22 Therefore, it is imperative to critically examine the legitimacy of art institutions shaped by intensified neoliberalism that followed globalization, the crises of democracy revealed in international politics, and the historical trajectory of global exhibitions as exemplified by the Gwangju Biennale.

Art Terms